Will FTC Separate Common Business Practices from New Consumer Harms in its Enforcement Policy?


Chapin Gregor
Last month, the Association for Competitive Technology (ACT) filed comments with the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) regarding its proposed enforcement policy statement covering personalized pricing. Sometimes called “algorithmic pricing” or even “surveillance pricing,” personalized pricing is the practice of changing the price presented to a customer based on personal data a business has about that customer. ACT weighed in to make sure FTC policymakers keep their sights on new consumer harms and don’t unintentionally sweep in common business practices that companies like our members and many others have long used.
In its proposed enforcement policy statement, the FTC identified two broad ways that companies using personalized pricing could be engaging in deception, namely
- presenting a price as static or widely offered when it is in fact personalized, and
- failing to disclose that a price is personalized and what personal data about a consumer the price is based on.
The Commission provided a number of examples that show the kind of things it has in mind:
- a grocery chain charging a higher price for milk when it knows a customer has kids at home
- a hotel charging more when it has data showing a consumer is in town for a funeral
In general, the FTC is concerned about differential pricing newly enabled by the vast amounts of personal data available on individuals in today’s digital world, particularly in situations that many of us would find upsetting.
That said, this is an area where policymakers need to make sure an enforcement policy against harmful behavior doesn’t sweep in a wide range of commonplace and positive business practices. Every scenario the FTC statement offers involves a retail, grocery, delivery, lodging, or rideshare price set higher because of what the seller infers about willingness to pay or about limited ability to shop elsewhere. None involves a price negotiated between businesses. ACT members buy software and cloud services, so clarity about when a quoted price is treated as personalized matters to them as purchasers and not only as sellers. The clarity ACT asks for applies the same way whether a member is quoting a price or being quoted one.
Many ACT members create software solutions for the technological needs of business clients. They may have default, off-the-shelf versions of their products or services, but they may also create custom solutions after learning more about their clients’ specific needs and situations. In fact, as ACT members know well, this flexibility and customizability is an important competitive advantage for small software development firms, allowing them to more nimbly react to nuanced challenges than large companies.
These customizable solutions, however, commonly lead to small firms like ACT’s members charging different prices to different clients for substantially similar products and services. For example, a developer serving two hospital systems with different integration and security requirements will quote each of them differently for work that looks similar from the outside. Small firms also offer different prices to different consumers during A/B testing, offering a new software subscription for $39, $59, or $99 and presenting prospective users with different prices at random to measure over time which price point generates the most revenue.
The enforcement policy statement says that liability for deception may attach “when a consumer reasonably believes that a price for a good or service is static or widely offered, and the merchant fails to disclose that the price is in fact personalized.” Because liability turns on what a customer reasonably expects, which the statement itself recognizes varies from one market to another, the limits of the policy get more difficult for small businesses to discern. Without clear guidance from the FTC that the new enforcement policy doesn’t apply to business-to-business deals or contracted work, or at least that it applies only to a narrower range of consumer harm, the Commission could wind up unintentionally affecting a broad swath of business practices that are common throughout the economy.
Because ACT members are both business owners and consumers, ACT seeks to educate policymakers to make sure consumer protection laws properly cover harmful practices without sweeping in commonplace economic activity.
Share this post

Resources
More action
Resources to understand more on the topic
Get in touch
Contact ACT
Whether you're a technology company looking to grow, or a policymaker seeking insight, we're here to help.
Get in touch to learn more about our work, explore membership, or connect with our team.
United States
United Kingdom
European Union

